To Far?

Having a career in advertising is like walking a tightrope. You have little room for error, and every decision you make has consciences. I think that we should be aware of other peoples feelings and do our best not to step on toes, but you can't please everyone. There are two ads that I think of in particular that walk that very thin line of correctness. One is an anti-smoking ad and the other is a absolute vodka ad. Both print ads, and both invoking troubling images for Americans in particular. Personally I don't have a problem with either, I think both are well designed and thought provoking. I just wanted to put them up here and see what other people think.